Is Algorithmic Trading Really Better Than Manual Trading?

[Mdraghib]

I’ve been reading a lot about algorithmic trading lately, and I’m curious about real experiences from traders here. Some say algorithms are the future of trading because they remove emotions and can execute faster than humans. Others argue that without a solid strategy, even the best code won’t help.

So my question is:
For those who have tried algorithmic trading, did it actually give you a consistent edge over manual trading? Or is success still mainly about strategy, market knowledge, and risk management?

[tradesprint]

Most traders prefer manual trading however if you have any specific trading strategy you can get it coded in to an EA to go automated.

[pradegxs]

Algos shine when they encode a tested rule set. I run a small EA for session range breaks and handle news/manual adds myself; what moved the needle was strict risk caps (max DD, per-trade %), not the code